What to mix with Skrewball Whiskey?

The Magic of Skrewball Whiskey: An Overview

If you’re a whiskey lover, chances are you’ve heard of Skrewball whiskey – the peanut butter-flavored whiskey that has taken the world by storm. Produced in California, this unique blend is made with premium whiskey and natural flavors, which give it a smooth and velvety texture with a hint of roasted peanuts.

Skrewball whiskey has quickly become one of the most popular whiskeys, loved by both traditionalists and adventurous spirit enthusiasts alike. Its popularity can be attributed to its versatility in cocktails; from classic mixers to unexpected ones, there’s no wrong way to enjoy this deliciously nutty drink.

The Versatility of Skrewball Whiskey in Cocktails

One of the best things about Skrewball Whiskey is how versatile it is when it comes to mixing it into cocktails. Whether you’re looking for something fruity or creamy, spicy or sour, Skrewball Whiskey can handle it all.

Skrewball’s nutty flavor pairs perfectly with citrusy mixers like soda water and lime juice for a refreshing twist. You can also add ginger ale or beer for a spicy kick that will make your taste buds dance.

Cola or root beer offer a more classic taste that adds depth to the peanut buttery notes. But Skrewball isn’t just limited to classic mixers; adding fruit juices opens up an entirely new realm of possibilities.

Pineapple juice and coconut cream give your cocktail a tropical vibe while cranberry juice and orange liqueur offer up sweet yet tangy goodness. For those chilly evenings by the fire, apple cider or juice with cinnamon syrup creates an irresistible cozy fall drink.

With its rich peanut butter flavor profile, creamy mixers are also great options for blending with Skrewball whiskey. Coffee liqueur and creamer make for an indulgent dessert-like cocktail while chocolate liqueur mixed with milk or cream satisfies your sweet tooth.

Irish cream with hazelnut syrup is a nutty twist on a classic favorite. Skrewball whiskey is so versatile that you can even experiment with unexpected mixers to create unique and exciting cocktails.

Hot sauce and lime juice add a spicy margarita-like drink, while lemonade and honey syrup create a refreshing summer sipper. Balsamic vinegar with strawberries and basil leaves adds depth to the whiskey’s flavor in an entirely new way.

Overall, Skrewball Whiskey is the perfect addition to any cocktail, offering up endless possibilities for experimentation. Whether you’re looking for something classic or completely out of the box, this nutty whiskey will surprise and delight your taste buds every time.

What to mix with Screwball Whiskey

Classic Mixer

There’s something to be said for sticking to the classics. After all, they’re classic for a reason! When it comes to mixing with Skrewball whiskey, there are a few tried-and-true mixers that are guaranteed to be crowd-pleasers.

1. Soda water and lime juice for a refreshing twist

This combo might seem simple, but the subtle tartness of the lime juice brings out the nuttiness of the whiskey while soda water keeps things light and refreshing. Plus, it’s easy to make – just pour a shot or two of Skrewball whiskey over ice, top with soda water and a splash of lime juice, and garnish with a lime wedge. It’s perfect for sipping on a sunny afternoon!

2. Ginger ale or beer for a spicy kick

If you’re looking for something with more bite, try mixing your Skrewball whiskey with ginger ale or beer. The spiciness of ginger pairs perfectly with the sweetness of peanut butter whiskey.

For an extra twist, add in some fresh ginger slices or muddle them at the bottom of your glass before pouring in the drink. Alternatively, if you want something even spicier, try mixing your Skrewball whiskey with your favorite beer – we recommend a hoppy IPA or pale ale.

This combination might sound weird at first glance but trust us – it works! Make sure to balance out the flavors by using equal parts beer and whiskey.

3. Cola or root beer for a classic taste

You can’t talk about classic mixers without mentioning cola or root beer! These fizzy drinks have been go-to mixers for generations because they pair so well with nearly any type of liquor – including Skrewball whiskey. To make a simple Skrewball and cola, fill a glass with ice, pour in your desired amount of whiskey, and top with cola.

To give it an extra kick, add a squeeze of fresh lemon juice. Alternatively, if you want to mix things up (no pun intended), try using root beer instead.

The earthy sweetness of the root beer pairs perfectly with the nuttiness of the whiskey for a delicious and nostalgic combination. Stay tuned for more creative ideas on what to mix Skrewball whiskey with!

Fruity Mixers

4. Pineapple juice and coconut cream for a tropical vibe

If you’re looking to escape to a tropical paradise, mix Skrewball whiskey with pineapple juice and coconut cream. The sweet tanginess of the pineapple pairs perfectly with the nutty flavor of the whiskey, while the creamy coconut adds a rich texture to the cocktail. To make this drink, fill a shaker with ice and add 1 1/2 oz. Skrewball whiskey, 3 oz. pineapple juice, and 1 oz. coconut cream.

Shake vigorously until well combined and strain into a tall glass filled with ice. Garnish with a slice of fresh pineapple or a sprig of mint for an extra pop of color.

5. Cranberry juice and orange liqueur for a sweet and tangy mix

For those who prefer their cocktails on the sweeter side, try mixing screwball whiskey with cranberry juice and orange liqueur for a refreshing combination of tartness and sweetness. The cranberry juice adds just enough tartness to balance out the sweetness of Screwball whiskey while orange liqueur helps brighten up its flavors. To make this cocktail fill shaker halfway with ice cubes then add 1 1/2 oz Screwball Whiskey, 2 oz Cranberry Juice Cocktail, half-ounce freshly squeezed lime juice, half-ounce Cointreau (or another orange-flavored liqueur) then shake well until chilled before straining into an old-fashioned glass over ice cubes.

6. Apple cider or juice with cinnamon syrup for cozy fall drink

Nothing is cozier than apple cider on chilly fall days (except maybe adding some cinnamon syrup). Mixing screwball whiskey with apple cider or apple juice provides just that cozy feel you need during autumn evenings in front of fireplaces.

Fill your shaker halfway with ice, and add in 1 1/2 oz. Screwball whiskey, 3 oz. apple cider or apple juice, and a splash of cinnamon syrup. Shake well and strain into a glass with ice.

Garnish with a cinnamon stick or slice of apple for the perfect fall touch. With these fruity mixers, you are guaranteed to have a delightful drink that will leave you wanting more!

Creamy Mixers

7. Coffee Liqueur and Creamer for an Indulgent Dessert-like Cocktail

If you’re a coffee lover, this Screwball whiskey drink is the perfect after-dinner indulgence. Simply mix 1 part coffee liqueur with 1 part creamer (half and half or heavy cream work well) and 2 parts Screwball whiskey. Shake well with ice, strain into a glass, and enjoy!

The creamy texture of the half and half or heavy cream combined with the coffee taste of the liqueur creates a dessert-like drink that’s perfect for sipping slowly while spending time with friends. Plus, the addition of Screwball whiskey adds a nutty flavor that perfectly complements the coffee taste.

8. Chocolate Liqueur with Milk or Cream to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth

If you have a sweet tooth, then this creamy Screwball whiskey cocktail is exactly what you need. Simply mix 1 part chocolate liqueur (such as Godiva or Baileys) with 2 parts milk or cream and 2 parts Screwball whiskey. Shake it all together with ice until it’s cold enough to chill your bones.

The chocolate liqueur adds a sinfully delicious chocolate taste that blends perfectly with the nutty flavor of the whiskey. The milk or cream helps to create a rich consistency that will leave you feeling satisfied without being too heavy.

9. Irish Cream with Hazelnut Syrup for a Nutty Twist

This twist on an Irish coffee calls for mixing equal parts Irish cream (such as Bailey’s) and Screwball whiskey, along with hazelnut syrup to taste. Add some ice if desired before shaking everything together in a cocktail shaker. The combination of Irish cream and Screwball creates an irresistibly smooth drink that is perfect for sipping during cozy nights in.

The addition of hazelnut syrup adds a nutty twist that perfectly complements the whiskey’s flavor. It’s also a great way to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day (or any day, really) with a fun and festive drink.

Unexpected Mixers

Mixing Screwball whiskey with unexpected ingredients can lead to some truly unique and flavorful drinks. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

10. Hot sauce and lime juice for a spicy margarita-like drink

If you love a little heat in your cocktails, try mixing Screwball whiskey with hot sauce and lime juice. This combination gives the drink a spicy kick that’s balanced out by the tangy citrus flavor of the lime juice.

To make this cocktail, add 1-2 dashes of hot sauce (depending on your tolerance for spice) and the juice of half a lime to 2 oz. of Screwball whiskey. Shake it up with ice and strain into a glass filled with ice.

This spicy margarita-like drink is perfect for sipping on warm summer evenings or enjoying during happy hour at home. It’s easy to make, but packs plenty of flavor.

11. Lemonade and honey syrup for a refreshing summer sipper

On hot days, nothing beats a cold glass of lemonade – except maybe lemonade spiked with Screwball whiskey! This refreshing summer sipper is made by combining 2 oz. of Screwball whiskey with 4 oz. of fresh lemonade and 1/2 oz. of honey syrup (which can be made by mixing equal parts honey and hot water until dissolved).

Serve over ice and garnish with a lemon wedge. The tartness of the lemonade is balanced out by the sweetness of the honey syrup, while the nutty flavor from the whiskey adds an unexpected twist to this classic beverage.

12. Balsamic vinegar with strawberries and basil leaves to add depth to the whiskey’s flavor

For something truly unique, try adding balsamic vinegar, fresh strawberries, and basil leaves to your Screwball whiskey cocktail. This combination may sound strange, but the sweetness of the strawberries and the tanginess of the balsamic vinegar work surprisingly well with the whiskey. Muddle a few sliced strawberries and a couple of basil leaves in a shaker, then add 2 oz. of Screwball whiskey and 1/2 oz. of balsamic vinegar.

Shake with ice and strain into a glass filled with ice. The result is a complex and flavorful drink that’s perfect for impressing your guests at your next dinner party or enjoying on your own as you unwind after a long day.


After exploring the various mixers that can be used with Screwball whiskey, it’s clear that the possibilities are endless. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cocktail or something unexpected, this versatile whiskey can accommodate any taste. Experimentation is key when finding your perfect drink, so don’t be afraid to try out different combinations until you find the one that satisfies your cravings.

One important thing to keep in mind when mixing drinks with Screwball whiskey is that it’s already quite sweet on its own. While some mixers can accentuate its nutty flavor, others may overpower it or make it too sugary.

It’s always a good idea to start with a small amount of mixer and add more as needed based on your personal preference. Another benefit of mixing drinks with Screwball whiskey is how easy they are to make at home.

With just a few simple ingredients and some creativity, you can impress your friends and family with delicious cocktails without spending a lot of money at a bar or restaurant. So go ahead and stock up on some mixers and let your imagination run wild!

Whether you’re hosting a party or just relaxing after work, try out different combinations until you find the perfect drink for any occasion. Cheers to enjoying Screwball whiskey in all its flavorful glory!

Similar Posts