Best Peanut Butter Whiskey

Spread the Love: A Guide to the Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Picks for a Unique Sipping Experience

The idea of peanut butter whiskey might seem strange at first, but it has quickly become a popular spirit among drinkers. The original and most well-known brand is Skrewball, which was created by a husband-and-wife team in San Diego, California.

The idea for Screwball came from the wife’s love for peanut butter and the husband’s experience as a bartender. They combined their passions to create a unique whiskey that could be enjoyed on its own or in cocktails.

Since then, several other brands have entered the market, each with their own spin on peanut butter whiskey. Sheep Dog and NutLiquor are two examples that have gained popularity in recent years.

Explanation of its Unique Taste and Popularity

Peanut butter whiskey might sound like an odd combination, but it actually makes perfect sense when you consider the flavor profiles of both peanut butter and whiskey. Peanut butter is sweet and creamy with a nutty undertone, while whiskey is often characterized by its smoky, oaky flavor.

When blended together, these two flavors complement each other to create a smooth and rich taste that’s unlike anything else on the market. Many people describe it as tasting like a boozy version of peanut butter cups or Reese’s Pieces.

The popularity of peanut butter whiskey can be attributed to both its unique taste and the viral social media posts that have helped spread awareness about it. Bartenders across the country have been experimenting with different ways to use peanut butter whiskey in cocktails, such as adding it to milkshakes or creating new twists on classic drinks like Old Fashioneds.

In addition to being versatile in cocktails, many people enjoy drinking peanut butter whiskey neat or on the rocks because it’s sweet enough to be sipped like a dessert liqueur but still packs a punch like traditional whiskey. In the next section, we will discuss the top picks for peanut butter whiskey and what makes each brand unique.

Top Picks for Peanut Butter Whiskey

If you are looking to try peanut butter whiskey, there are a wide variety of options available on the market. Here are our top picks:

Screwball is the brand that started it all. This San Diego-based distillery created a peanut butter whiskey that took the market by storm, leading to a huge trend in peanut butter-flavored spirits.

Screwball is a smooth and creamy whiskey with a strong peanut butter flavor that leaves a pleasant aftertaste. It can be enjoyed on its own over ice or used in cocktails for an inventive twist on classic recipes.

If you’re not sure where to start with peanut butter whiskey, Screwball is definitely the go-to choice. Its popularity has led to its widespread availability across the US and beyond, so finding a bottle should be relatively easy.

Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey: A Smooth and Creamy Option with a Hint of Vanilla

For those looking for something slightly different than Skrewball, we recommend Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey. This option has a similar smoothness to Screwball but adds in hints of vanilla for an extra layer of flavor complexity.

The sweetness of Sheep Dog makes it perfect for dessert-style cocktails or sipping neat as an after-dinner drink. It’s also great when paired with desserts like pies or cakes as it complements their flavors perfectly while offering an interesting contrast.

NutLiquor Peanut Butter Whiskey: A More Affordable Option with Strong Peanut Butter Flavor

If you’re on a budget but still want to try out some tasty peanut butter whiskey, NutLiquor might be the choice for you. This brand offers a more affordable option with a strong peanut butter flavor that will satisfy your craving. NutLiquor is a great choice for those who want to experiment with peanut butter whiskey without breaking the bank.

While it may not be as smooth as other brands, NutLiquor’s strong peanut butter profile makes it an excellent ingredient in cocktails or pairings with savory dishes like BBQ or grilled meats. It’s also worth trying in baking recipes that call for whiskey, adding an interesting twist to classic recipes like chocolate cake or bread pudding.

These three brands are our top picks for those looking to try out this unique twist on whiskey. Whether you opt for the original Skrewball, the smooth Sheep Dog, or the more affordable NutLiquor, you’re sure to be impressed by this innovative spirit.

Best Peanut Butter Whiskey

How to Enjoy Peanut Butter Whiskey

Peanut butter whiskey has a unique taste that may take some getting used to, but once you do, it can be enjoyed in a variety of ways. Here are some popular ways to drink peanut butter whiskey:

Neat or on the rocks for a pure taste experience

The best way to experience the full flavor of peanut butter whiskey is by drinking it neat or on the rocks. This means enjoying it without any mixers or chasers, allowing you to taste the sweetness and smoothness of the peanut butter flavor. Drinking it on the rocks can also help to mellow out any burn from the alcohol and make it easier to sip slowly.

It’s important to note that peanut butter whiskey is typically stronger than regular whiskey, with an ABV (alcohol by volume) around 35-40%. It’s recommended that you start off with small sips and gradually work your way up if you’re new to drinking it neat.

In cocktails, such as a PB&J Old Fashioned or a Nutty Irishman

Peanut butter whiskey can also be used in cocktails for those who prefer a sweeter drink with more complexity. A popular cocktail is the PB&J Old Fashioned, which combines Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey with raspberry liqueur and bitters for a fruity twist on a classic cocktail.

Another option is the Nutty Irishman, which adds Bailey’s Irish Cream and coffee liqueur to peanut butter whiskey for a creamy dessert-like drink. Other cocktails that use peanut butter whiskey include milkshakes, martinis, and even Margaritas!

As a dessert pairing, such as with chocolate or ice cream

If you have more of a sweet tooth, consider pairing peanut butter whiskey with desserts like chocolate cake or ice cream. The nutty flavor of the whiskey complements the richness of the chocolate and creates a decadent combination.

For example, you can pour peanut butter whiskey over vanilla or chocolate ice cream for a boozy dessert. Or, use it in a sauce or glaze for baked goods like brownies or cookies.

There are endless possibilities for incorporating peanut butter whiskey into your favorite desserts. There are many ways to enjoy peanut butter whiskey depending on your taste preferences.

Whether you prefer it neat, in a cocktail, or paired with desserts, there’s no denying its unique and delicious flavor. So next time you’re looking for something different to drink or serve at a party, consider giving peanut butter whiskey a try!

The Rise in Popularity of Peanut Butter Whiskey

Social Media Influence and Viral Videos

In recent years, social media has played a significant role in the rise of peanut butter whiskey’s popularity. Videos featuring the unique spirit have gone viral on platforms such as TikTok and Instagram, garnering millions of views and shares from curious viewers. These videos often showcase creative ways to enjoy peanut butter whiskey, such as mixing it with chocolate syrup or making a milkshake with it.

One video in particular, posted by @tallblondemisfit on TikTok, features a recipe for a peanut butter whiskey hot cocoa that quickly gained popularity among users. The video has over 1 million likes and thousands of comments from viewers who have tried the recipe themselves.

Expansion into Mainstream Bars and Restaurants

Beyond social media influence, many bars and restaurants have also started to offer peanut butter whiskey on their menus due to its increasing popularity. It’s not uncommon to see specialty cocktails featuring the unique spirit at trendy bars or even mainstream chain restaurants.

One example is The Cheesecake Factory’s “Peanut Butter Cup Martini”, which features Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey mixed with vodka, chocolate syrup, and cream. The drink has become a favorite among customers at the popular restaurant chain.

Appeal to Those Who Enjoy Sweet, Dessert-Like Drinks

Peanut butter whiskey’s sweet taste profile also plays a significant role in its growing popularity. As more consumers look for drinks that satisfy their sweet tooth without being overly sugary or artificial tasting, peanut butter whiskey offers a unique alternative.

Many fans of the spirit enjoy mixing it with other sweet flavors like chocolate or coffee liqueur to create dessert-like cocktails. Its smooth texture also makes it an excellent addition to creamy drinks like milkshakes or hot cocoa.

A Sweet and Unique Spirit Gaining Mainstream Popularity

Overall, the rise in popularity of peanut butter whiskey can be attributed to a combination of factors, including social media influence, expansion into mainstream bars and restaurants, and its appeal to those who enjoy sweet, dessert-like drinks. As more consumers become aware of this unique spirit, it’s likely that we’ll continue to see it featured on menus and in homes across the country.

Best Peanut Butter Whiskey

Lesser-Known Facts About Peanut Butter Whiskey

Its origins in San Diego, California

Peanut butter whiskey may seem like a recent creation, but it actually has roots in San Diego, California. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey was first created by a husband and wife team in their own kitchen as a way to combine their love of peanut butter and whiskey. They started selling the drink at local events and festivals, quickly gaining popularity among friends and neighbors.

Eventually, their homemade concoction became so popular that they decided to turn it into a fully fledged business. Today, Skrewball is one of the most well-known brands of peanut butter whiskey on the market.

The use of real peanuts in the distilling process

One of the things that sets peanut butter whiskey apart from other flavored whiskeys is its use of real peanuts in the distilling process. Most other flavored whiskeys rely on artificial flavors or extracts to achieve their taste profiles, but peanut butter whiskey uses actual peanuts to create its unique flavor.

The peanuts are roasted before being added to the mash during fermentation. This results in a smooth and creamy taste with subtle notes of roasted peanuts.

Its versatility in cooking recipes, such as marinades or glazes

While most people think of drinking whiskey when they hear about peanut butter whiskey, it’s actually quite versatile when it comes to cooking as well. The sweet and nutty flavor pairs well with all kinds of dishes, from savory marinades for chicken or pork to sweet glazes for cakes or cookies. One popular recipe involves using peanut butter whiskey as an ingredient in a barbecue sauce for ribs or pulled pork – it adds just the right amount of sweetness and depth without overpowering the other flavors.

The future growth potential for Peanut Butter Whiskey

Peanut butter whiskey is still a relatively new addition to the world of flavored whiskeys, but it’s already making waves in the industry. Its unique taste and viral social media presence have helped make it a popular choice for younger drinkers who are looking for something different from traditional whiskey. As more people discover peanut butter whiskey and its versatility in cocktails and cooking, its popularity is likely to continue growing.

Some experts predict that peanut butter whiskey could become as popular as other flavored whiskeys like honey or cinnamon in the coming years. Only time will tell whether this prediction comes true, but one thing is for sure – peanut butter whiskey is here to stay.


Peanut butter whiskey is a unique and delicious twist on traditional whiskey, and there are several top picks to choose from. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey remains the most popular brand, known for its smooth and creamy taste with a strong peanut butter flavor. Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey offers an extra hint of vanilla, while NutLiquor Peanut Butter Whiskey provides an affordable option without sacrificing taste.

There are several ways to enjoy peanut butter whiskey, including drinking it neat or on the rocks for a pure tasting experience. It can also be used in cocktails such as a PB&J Old Fashioned or a Nutty Irishman.

Additionally, peanut butter whiskey can be paired with dessert items like chocolate or ice cream for an indulgent treat. The rise in popularity of peanut butter whiskey can be attributed to its appeal on social media platforms and viral videos showcasing unique drink recipes.

Its expansion into mainstream bars and restaurants has also made it more accessible to the general public. Additionally, those who enjoy sweet dessert-like drinks have gravitated towards this unique twist on traditional whiskey.

Peanut butter whiskey is a delicious alternative to traditional whiskey that offers a unique twist on the classic drink. There are several top picks to choose from and various ways to enjoy it – whether neat or mixed in cocktails.

Whether you’re already a fan of this innovative drink or just trying it out for the first time, there’s no denying that it’s quickly becoming one of the most popular drinks around – so why not give it a try? Cheers!

Similar Posts